Over the last few seasons, I’ve spent a fair amount of time musing about The Curse Of Fourth but then QPR earned a jammy victor over Derby a year ago and so this year it’ll have to be The Disadvantage Of Finishing Fourth. Unfortunately, my old laptop has finally given up the ghost and may have taken all my spreadsheets with it; as I also have a family birthday to attend this weekend, this preview is an overview. With any luck, I’ll be able to write a comprehensive preview for the final.
Brentford
Last ten games: 4-4-2
Record against the other playoff teams: 1-1-4 (lost twice to Middesbrough, failed to score in both games)
Playoff record: losing semi finalists 1990/91, 1994/95, 2004/05, 2005/06 (third tier), losing finalists 1996/97, 2001/02, 2012/13 (third tier)
Doesn’t look good does it? You don’t qualify for the playoffs by being an average team but it’s pretty clear to me that those four defeats in six games against their immediate rivals indicate that the Bees aren’t good enough to go any further this season. How they react to any potential disappointment will be crucial, especially as Mark Warburton will be leaving as soon as the season is over. Getting this far might be the high point in this particuar era at Griffin Park; the Bees are the first team to reach the Championship playoffs after having won promotion from League One at the end of the previous season since Bristol City in 2008 and that didn’t end well for the Robins.
Ipswich
Last ten games: 5-2-3
Record against the other playoff teams: 2-1-3 (lost twice to Norwich, failed to score in either game)
Playoff record: losing semi finalists 1986/87, 1996/97, 1997/98, 1998/99, 2003/04, 2004/05 (all second tier)
The signs of a revival in the fortunes of the Tractor Boys started when Mick McCarthy took over the reigns at Portman Road in November 2012 and the incremental improvement – including a very good defensive record at home – has resulted in their first playoff spot for a decade, but the sad truth is that Ipswich have been victimised by their near neighbours recently. Their playoff history is disastrous and sixth placed teams do not have a good record in the Championship playoffs. Last winners: Blackpool in 2010. Even if Town don’t go up, I doubt they’ll be playing in League One in five years time.
Middlesbrough
Last ten games: 6-1-3
Record against the other playoff teams: 5-0-1 (beat Brentford by an aggregate score of 5-0)
Playoff record: losing semi finalists 1990/91 (second tier)
In form, good record against the other three teams but although there’s no longer a full blown Curse of Fourth, it’s fair to say that over the last decade fourth placed teams have not done well. One win – last season – and three losses in four finals in that period does not bode well. That being said, Boro had the best defensive record in the Championship in 2014/15 based on a very tight record at the Riverside (only Sheffield Wednesday scored more than twice) and my initial doubts about Aitor Karanka’s suitability for the job have long since disappeared. So basically in a good position to return to the Premier League after six seasons in the second tier, just as long as Karanka doesn’t send Dimitrios Konstantinopoulous up for a corner…
Norwich
Last ten games: 6-3-1
Record against the other playoff teams: 3-0-3 – only one side scored in all of those games, which the punters amongst you might want to take note of.
Playoff record: none.
Arguably the in form team of the quartet, but their form against the other three teams is either boom or bust and they have no previous form in the post season. Not only that they somehow managed to lose twice against an unremarkable Reading side this season, but the Canaries failed to beat Rotherham and also lost both games against Middlesbrough without scoring. Alex Neil has been an excellent appointment but he may have to finish the job next season. Third placed clubs have reached the final in eight of the last ten seasons, but have only won half of those finals. The last triumph in the Championship playoffs by a third placed team was West Ham, who’d also been relegated from the Premier League at the end of theprevious season.
Verdict: Norwich are the favourites to reach the final at the very least, but over the last decade newly relegated teams are three times more likely to lose in the semis as they are to win the whole thing. That leaves the door open for Middlesbrough, who ultimately lost out on automatic promotion after that mad game at Fulham but who weren’t that far off the pace of either Bournemouth or Watford. Ipswich are an intriguing prospect and could be amongst the pacesetters in the autumn; Brentford are a genuine wild card, but both of them face an uphill battle in the semi finals.